Teacher Notes - Crossing the Line

 

The following letter was a long time in coming...

February 5, 2001

Dear County and District Superintendents, Curriculum Leaders Certificated and Classified Employees:

I am pleased to announce that recently enacted legislation (Senate Bill 984-Polanco) asks schools to celebrate the life and work of Cesar Chavez, a great American, on Cesar Chavez Day. This year's celebration occurs on March 30, and the California Department of Education will be supporting it in a number of ways.

Cesar Chavez Day recognizes one of the state's great leaders who fought injustice and created a coalition for civil rights that was unprecedented in this state's history. I ask all educators to support this day through education and community service. Californians can celebrate the values of service, sacrifice, tolerance, determination, and nonviolence that guided the way in which Chavez lived his life.

My staff has created a web-based resource center for Cesar Chavez Day, (http://www.cde.ca.gov/cesarchavez). To aid schools and teachers, we have provided various resources, including a biography of Cesar Chavez, a list of instructional materials, a document showing how the standards and curriculum framework support the day, a compilation of curricula developed by California's districts, and links to other useful Internet-based materials.

The service learning aspect of Cesar Chavez Day is being administered through the Commission on Improving Life Through Service, (http://www.chavezday.ca.gov) , with assistance from the Department's CALServe program, (http://www.cde.ca.gov/calserve).

While Cesar Chavez Day is an important holiday, the sponsoring legislation also calls for the life, work, and philosophy of Cesar Chavez to be part of every school's curriculum throughout the year. The History-Social Science Framework for California Public Schools specifically references Cesar Chavez, and the Department has developed curriculum guidelines to foster teaching and learning about him. These guidelines are available on the CDE website at (http://www.cde.ca.gov/cesarchavez).

The Department will continue its efforts to support schools in teaching about Cesar Chavez. Later this month, a request for proposals to develop a full Cesar Chavez curriculum, called for and funded by the legislation, will be released at http://www.cde.ca.gov/cesarchavez. In 2002, the Department will make this curriculum available to school districts.

Thank you for helping to honor one of California's great figures.

Sincerely,

DELAINE EASTIN

State Superintendent of Public Instruction

 

The story of Cesar Chavez is an important one. In a world that is currently reeling from the events of September 11, our students will need role models for nonviolent social activism. The History-Social Science Framework for California Public Schools have always maintained that teachers should "encourage students to reflect on the individual responsibility and behavior that create a good society, to consider the individual's role in how a society governs itself, and to examine the role of law in society...what the state owes to its citizens, and what citizens owe to the state...Students should be given opportunities to lead and to follow. They should learn how to select leaders and how to resolve disputes rationally...and should learn to respect the rights of the minority, even if this minority is only a singe dissenting voice."

Lesson Purpose

The story of Cesar Chavez and his struggle for social justice does not begin in the sixties. The story of Mexican and Mexican-American migrant workers goes back to early California and Southwest agricultural history. Like many Mexican-Americans, Cesar Chavez's family was living in the United States before the border was sealed. And like so many farm laborers their chances of achieving the American dream were shattered during the time of the Great Depression. It is my hope that by the end of this unit, students will consider the qualities of a hero and realize that one person can make a difference.

Length of Lesson

To complete the entire lesson as written will take from 3-4 weeks. Once the students have started Task One, they could begin working on Tasks Two and Three. However, I recommend allowing them the time to complete Task One before beginning the next since the activities are scaffolded in terms of higher-level thinking.

Lesson Sequence

Day 1

I recommend beginning the unit by having students listen to several interviews from the Library of Congress Voices From the Dust Bowl Collection. As they listen to the actual voices of Mexican migrant workers Jose Flores and Augustus Martinez, you might want to give them a copy of the National Archives Sound Recording Analysis Worksheet. The main question should be "what can these interviews tell us about living conditions for migrant workers during the Great Depression?" Ask students to share what they know about working and living conditions for migrant workers today.

For an instant glimpse into the life of migrant children, I recommend reading Linda Jacob Altman's Amelia's Road and Juan Felipe Herrera's Calling the Doves. You might combine these two storybooks with several biographical pieces from Beth Atkins's Voices from the Fields.

Day 2

Brainstorm what students already know about Cesar Chavez. Discuss the expression "crossing the line." Can they think of examples where someone they know or know of has "crossed the line"?

Day 3

Ask students to write down the qualities they associate with heroes. Have them list several people who they believe meet these qualifications and explain why. Create a class chart on hero qualities.

For homework ask the students to interview an adult about a person he/she considers to be a hero and why. To guide students in this interview process, provide them with a copy of the Scoring Guide for an Interview.

Day 4

Assign teams to begin Task One. Students will need two weeks to complete the visual portion of the project and an additional week to prepare their oral presentations.

Guiding the Process

I recommend holding daily briefings with each group to check on their progress with Task One. This will allow you to monitor their progress, guide their efforts, verify individuals' efforts and add whatever other help may be needed. It is crucial that students understand the need for starting each class period in an organized fashion with a defined purpose for that day.

Final Project

Treat Task One as a real event. Allowing your students the opportunity to teach younger children the lessons of Cesar Chavez is an example of service learning in itself.

Adaptations for Special Needs Students

Since this project involves research, writing, and layout, you may wish to assign the tasks within groups so that each student can both work to a strength and develop an area in which he or she is not yet strong. Students with limited skills might be encouraged to use only one website as a resource, so they can spend more time with writing and creating the visual presentation.

Extension Activities

Create a Wall of Heroes as a permanent exhibit in your classroom or school. Highlighting day-to-day acts of heroism is an excellent way to encourage our students to become informed, compassionate citizens who realize the impact of their own actions on the feelings and lives of others.

Note: Cesar E. Chavez's image is used with permission of the Cesar E. Chavez Foundation.